One World One Heart Giveaway has started!
Etsy Team Columbus is a connected group of artists, artisans, and craftspeople in Columbus, Ohio. We work collaboratively for the mutual creative and professional benefit of everyone in the group.
Our giveaway is a combo gift pack from several artists in ETC! We will divide the prized gifts into 2 gift bags! So 2 lucky winners will be announced on Feb 15th!! can't beat that! How to win you ask? Just leave a comment below, it's that easy! Have fun and visit and support as many blogs as our mouse will let you!
Be sure to check back or subscribe to our blog for our February Variety Charity Boxes
Our giveaway is a combo gift pack from several artists in ETC! We will divide the prized gifts into 2 gift bags! So 2 lucky winners will be announced on Feb 15th!! can't beat that! How to win you ask? Just leave a comment below, it's that easy! Have fun and visit and support as many blogs as our mouse will let you!Be sure to check back or subscribe to our blog for our February Variety Charity Boxes
Written by
Tags:








215 comments:
Fantastic giveaway! I love it.
Your work is brilliant.
Please enter my name! Pop over to my blog (#59 on the magic carpet) for a chance to win, too! :D
Wonderful Giveaway. Linda:). Please pop me in the Hat, and do drop in and visit if you have time.. http://artwolfs-briar-rose-gate.blogspot.com/
This is great thanks!
love those earrings!
cant wait to see ya'll at Eco Chic Craftacular in May!
This looks like a great giveaway! Lots of talented folks contributing! That little journal is so neat!
Thank you for sharing. Your team sounds like fun and sisterhood.
#690 OWoh
great work guys, lovely to see people working as a team. plz count me in. my blog is http://paperfanatic.blogspot.com
A great giveaway ... Thank you for the opportunity to win :0) I am having so much fun riding the magic carpet :0)
Please take the time to join in my giveaway here
Thank you X
OWOH ticket number 226
Hi Linda :)
Lovely giveaway!Pls count me in and if you want, pls take a moment to visit my #55 on Magic Carpet :)
Thank you for the chance to win!
Hugs,
Mila :)
Hello!
would love to win! :)
What a great giveaway! I'd love a chance to win.
Please add me!!!
Blessings,Flora
A wonderful prize for this mixed media artist!
Please count me in and visit my blog as well!
Eileen
eyeleeeen at optonline dot net
http://artsaveslives-paperqueen.blogspot.com
(I will be out of the country from 2/14 to 2/20, so if I am fortunate enough to win, PLEASE wait til I return and can claim the wonderful prize!)
January 28, 2010 3:14 AM
Yah! I want to be one of the winners! Looks like you have great giveaways!
Great giveaway! Please enter my name! Pop over to my blog (#92 on the magic carpet) for a chance to win, too! :)
Ohhh another team giveaway..ours is doing one too..Magical Holiday Artists!! Oh what wonderful treats...please add me to the list!
Please pop by mine and drop your name in my hat too!
Sarah @ Cottage Garden Studios #158
What a collection of wonderful items you are offering. Please include me in your drawing.
jodaeodesign@gmail.com
http://jodeaodesign.blogspot.com/
Wonderful!
Wonderful giveaway! Please do include me in your drawing and thank you so much!
http://therunninggarlic.wordpress.com #61
Lovely giveaway prizes! There are so many talented artists on Etsy Team Columbus.
Thank you all for hopping aboard this magic carpet ride. I hope you get a chance to visit my blog, #258 on your journey.
Hugs from ON, Canada
Heidi
heidig@gmail.com
What a great giveaway! Thank you for the chance to win. - Krystal http://kryssiruss.blogspot.com/ (kryssi01@msn.com)
Thanks for offering this great giveaway and Thanks so much for a chance to win! chiggerlane@aol.com
Such a wonderful idea to promote each other as a team! We crafters need to stick together! Thanks for the chance to win! uffda_68787@yahoo.com
Wonderful giveaway! Love it.
Pam
Hmm... I really need an oven mitt!! Please include me in your draw, and feel free to enter mine too :)
Thank you for the opportunity to win this amazing giveaway! Please enter my stamping blog give away too. I'm #199 on the magic carpet!
hugs Susi from Vienna, Austria
Etsy goodness - Hooray!
Deborah
comfortjoydesigns AT gmail DOT com
I am so delighted to meet all of the wonderful blogs along the Magic Carpet Ride excursion! I am having so much fun meeting new people who are of like kind in so many ways. Your work is beautiful and I would love to be entered in your drawing. Please stop by to enter my beaded bracelet giveaway!
Sharon (#52)
http://shardonexclusives.blogspot.com
Please enter my name for a chance to win one of the bags. #649
Nice meeting you here in the blogosphere.
Love your blog and giveaway!
Visit my OWOH blog (#7) at Loose Ends and take a chance on winnning my giveaway too!
Wonderful giveaway!! Please enter me :)
Please enter me in your drawing.
Thank you for giving me this opportunity to join in on the fun.
Go Bucks!!!! Thanks for the chance!
o what fun
I'd love a chance to win your prizes!
Angie
#43
blog celebration & great giveaway, count me in!
I'm having fun blog hopping and joining all the giveaways that are inspiring to me.
Thank you for sharing I have my fingers crossed.
Pop on over to number 671 and visit mine too.
xo
OMG! This giveaway is so awesome! Please count me in :)
What a fabulous giveaway. Please enter me, thank you.
Beautiful creation! Wonderful! Thanks for the giveaway!
Amy
artsyrockerchick@aim.com
OHOW #680/681
Great giveaway! Thanks for having this-- please throw my name into the hat. :) And don't forget to pop over to my blog for a chance to win prizes, too! #318 on the magic carpet...
Great concept. We are trying to get something similar going here in our town!! Kuddos!! Thanks for sharing you offerings with us!! :::Smiles::: Shelly OWOH #435
Ok. Well that's just AMAZING! Put me in the draw!
Sounds like fun !! Count me in. I'm #86 , stop by if you have a chance
Great Give away.. Thanks so much for entering my name for a chance to win..
Hop on the Magic Carpet and fly over to my blog to enter for my prize. Isn't this fun!
xoxo
((((hugs))))
Maggie
What a great way to share your work together. So wonderful when you can all come together. Enjoy the blogging event.
Great way to grow together as artists.
What a box of goodies! Count me in!
Grace Hester Designs
Silhouette- and typography- based artwork and prints
Shop my designs at http://gracehesterdesigns.etsy.com
Grace Hester Services
Helping Etsy Sellers with Marketing and Design Needs
View services at http://gracehesterservices.etsy.com
Experience my blog at http://gracehester.typepad.com
Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/gracehester
What a fun giveaway, so many awesome treasures. I would love to be entered.
debby
Please enter me in your draw! Also pop over to my blog, have a browse around and enter my give away. I’m number 303 on the magic carpet :)
Cool! I'm glad I found you. Nice giveaway.
Enter me up Scotty!
Thanks!
blog celebration & great giveaway, count me in!
What a fabulous giveaway!!!
If you can, please come and visit me at #701. :)
hello there! what a beautiful prize - please enter me into the giveaway
feel free to fly on over to my blog here and i hope you enjoy your magic carpet ride :)
I'd love to be entered in your generous giveaway!
I'm participating for the first time, so stop by my blog & enter my giveaway, too! #344
Thank you for a chance to win such a great offering!!
OWOH #473
Thanks so much for the generous giveaway I would be delighted to win
tanyainjville@yahoo.com
What a great giveaway! Please toss my name in the hat
Love the goodies. Thank you for the chance to win.
Judee
jlefler at mi-connection dot com
Great giveaway!
Greetings from Ohio, USA
Gabriela
treasuregab@yahoo.com
OWOH #322
Beautiful creations.
Thanks for the chance to win.
Hope you have a wonderful day.
=) melanie
What a delightful giveaway!
Ohio Crafters Yay! Great work! Please count me in and fly over to my carpet for a chance to win something too!
Fingers Crossed!
474. The Muse Factory
SOunds fantastic! I'd love to win some goodies made by talented artists!
Great! count me in please.~~Becky
What a lovely selection of goodies. Please count me in. Susan #710
What a great give-away event!, you make beautiful things!
greetings from the Netherlands!
Anyyone would be lucky to win them :)
Come ad visit me :) http://natureswhispers.blogspot.com/
just great stuff, enter my name please
#631
x
Lovely gifts, thanks for the chance to win. Fly over to my blog and enter mine.
i would love to win this giveaway!
yes! please toss my name in the hat!
Thank you for the lovely opportunity! please visit my part of the ride too: #783
Tracy
TX, USA
I love surprises and handmade is always the best surprise of all.
Elizabeth
OWOH #79
Very engaging gift pack.
I’d love to be entered in your drawing. Stop by my blogs to be entered in mine.
WW
http://www.thefrogprincess-ww.blogspot.com/
http://www.weinkswonders.blogspot.com/
Really nice giveaway!
Please enter me in the draw and don’t forget to enter mine.
oooh what a gorgeous mix of things i would love to open this up! please count me in :)
isn't this fun?? #822 sewgorgeous.blogspot.com
Oh how fun! So many incredible pieces!
Great idea to work as a team! Looks like you are a very creative bunch!
How wonderful! What neat things! Please enter my name and visit me soon, too! ♥ http://lavenderdreamstoo.blogspot.com/
I love surprises, please count me in.
http://busybeefree.blogspot.com/
Hi from Olmsted Falls, OH! (suburb of cleveland)
those are great gifts you've assembled.
Please PICK ME to win in your giveaway drawing! thank you.
I will back to visit after the event.
Greetings from Moldova!
Gorgeous giveaway!!!!
Thanks!
OWOH #138
http://miawoo.blogspot.com/
fancyscrap[at]gmail.com
Lovely,lovely! I would love to be entered to win your wonderful gift!
http://wondrousstrangedesigns.blogspot.com/
Please stop by and enter my give away as well! I'm number 290
hello columbus! i was born not far from you. thanks for the chance.
What wonderful prizes! Thank you for the chance to win. If you have time, come by my blog and check out my giveaway. I'm #855
What a package of gorgeous goodies! Thank you for this amazing giveaway! count me in, xo Mendy
Yay for a team effort! I'd love to see more of the lovelies you make. And the charity boxes are a great idea! Glad you joined the Ride!
carapacenator(at)gmail.com
www.caramakes.blogspot.com
OWOH Ticket Holder #21
All of your goodies are absolutely beautiful! Please enter my name into your fabulous drawing for a chance to win.
Also, I would love for you to stop by my blog to enter my giveaway - #548.
Thanks,
Jenn
Cool giveaway, would love to be entered
Ohhhh..., you are one talented team!
Please throw my name in the hat and please fly on the Magic Carpet to Australia where you can win an Artsy Linen Eco Bag!
I am Ticket Holder #873
Julie xxx
Hi :)
I just love the wonderful opportunity to travel the world on a magic carpet and visit so many wonderful people :)
Love your giveaway, and I would love a chance to win :) if you haven't already then, please stop by my blog, there's a giveaway there too, and I'd love it if you'd enter !!
Hugs and thanks,
Linda from Norway
Wonderful! Please enter my name!
Please stop by and ride my magic carpet too!
http://inspiringadventuresofalwaysinspired.blogspot.com/
Wow, what a fantastic array of beautiful goodies. I'd be thrilled to have a chance to win them.
What a wonderful assortment!fe
I cross my fingers to be the lucky winner of your fantastic giveaway
Pat de Verr from french Riviera
Great giveaway! Please enter me :)
memoriesforlifescrapbooks at hotmail dot com
Feel free to enter my giveaway as well: http://memoriesforlifescrapbooks.blogspot.com/2010/01/one-world-one-heart-giveaway.html
Wonderful giveaway and items! Please count me in :)
Thanks for the chance of your giveaway, I hope you can come see mine here (if you haven’t already!)
Sherry from England, UK (ticket #251)
Hi Etsy Team, what a lovely idea and post you have. I love the gorgeous surprise bags. I'd love to win. I absolutely love your gifts. Please take time to visit my blog, too, for a chance to win my book, 16 x MOM: A Mastery of Motherhood. I'm working on getting all the country flags. I promise to revisit your's too.
#784
http://blog.barbaracagle.com
www.barbaracagle.com
*•: -:¦:-**•: -:¦:-**•: -:¦:-*
How Marvelous!
Please count me in!
Hugs,
Gina Luna
http://inginasworld.blogspot.com/
*•: -:¦:-**•: -:¦:-**•: -:¦:-*
Nice work you do in Columbus! I especially like the pink felt snowflake ornament! I've bookmarked your etsy shop as a favourite! Please enter my name in your draw -- thank you!!
~martha (#180)
What a great idea and group! Please enter me in your giveaway and thank you for the opportunity.
Cheers! Beck
(#349 Sarcastic Quilter)
Lovely! Thanks for the chance.
Hi from Minnesota.
Your giveaways are great! Thanks for the chance to win! (I'm #811)
HBKHotie1@msn.com
Your giveaway looks lovely-thankyou for the chance!
Elaine R
emrosser@shaw.ca
what a great giveaway. thanks so much for the opportunity to enter the drawing. so delighted to meet you through this event. I hope you'll stop by my blog as well.
Nice to meet you and visit your blog! Love this giveaway! I am having so much fun looking at all the wonderful blogs. I don't have a blog, due to arthritis I cannot type much at all but I enjoy surfing the net. Thank you for a chance to win.
Great giveaway, I'm signing up to follow.....
Take care,
Donna
dwarrington1@gmail.com
*´*•.¸ ★•*´*•Superb!•*´*•★¸.•*´*•
Please count me in!
XOXO
Rich Witch
Please visit me for a chance to win a Most Magical Prize at:
http://rich-witch.blogspot.com/
*´*•.¸ ★ ¸.•*´*•*´*•.¸ ★ ¸.•*´*•
Sounds great! Count me in please.
OWOH 537
What a wonderful giveaway! Please enter me in it.
Thank you and have a lovely day!
Mari
marilavado (at) gmail.com
Please add my name to the hat :o)
Adorable giveaway! Count me in! thanks!
Great giveaway...count me in please.
What a fantastic giveaway, I'd love to win it! I’m also participating in One World One Heart. Please come by my blog and leave a comment to have a chance to win what I'm giving away.
Cheryl
http://cheryl-comfort.blogspot.com/
I think it's a clever idea! I’d love to be included in your draw.
Do drop by mine when you can: http://aunexamor.net/entula/2010/02/02/one-world-one-heart/
Aelyn
OWOH #931
What a great idea!
Please count me in :-)
Sadie x
OWOH #962
I'd love to win!
Thanks for an enchanting stop on the magic carpet!
Outrageous joy,
Kathy over at Everyday Bliss
#111 on the blog tour
it is great to see a team work together!
that sounds like one fab give away!! As Nico says - it's great to see a team work together!!
I love the idea of a local etsy team- wish there was somethiing like that where I am- for the encouragement and cheerleading. Please add my name to you generous giveaway and have fun blog hopping.
Oh yes, please enter me in your lovely giveaway, I would so love to win!! If you haven't already, make sure you come by and enter mine as well, I'm #116. Thank you:-) xox
A pack with goodies from different artists! How wonderful would that be!
Li
(I'm participating this year too. Here's my post link: OWOH 2010: A Little Friend For You Too)
Greetings from NW Arkansas! Please enter me into your fantastic drawing and be sure to stop by my blog for a chance to win, too. #56
Hi dear!!! I like your idea! It’s very Awesome! I wish to ALL who will participate in this wondefull give-away, Big Good Luck! Yohooooo! ;)
What a fantastic giveaway! Please enter me into your drawing. I hope I win! :]
briannarocko@yahoo.com
pls count me in for your giveaway pack of goodies from different artists. i love surprises!
Your work is gorgeous! Thanks for the chance to win!
Donna
sodapop@ptialaska.net
what a lovely offering!
please drop by my blog #774!
blessings,
abigail
great combined give away
please count me in
my magic carpet number is # 397
Thanks Team for the chance to win your generous and lovely gifts. The journal looks wonderful. thanks for the chance to win. Please come by my place #70 and enter my draw. Great meeting you.
Rob
I love your values and this giveaway, please count me in.
When you get some time, please fly by my blog on your magic carpet, I am OWOH #907.
Thank you much for participaitn in OWOH.
It is so very very nice to meet you.
Thanks for the chance to win, its lovely. Trianna from Victoria Canada. tricklestogether@hotmail.com
http://triannastreasures.blogspot.com
Great blog! Please count my in :) Hope your having a fab weekend! Please do pop by my blog to join in my giveaway :)
Thanks
Much Love
Rachel in Scotland
What a great collection of goodies!! Please enter me in your giveaway, thanks! Amanda
amanda31gifts@gmail.com
amanda31gifts.blogspot.com
p.s. - visit me at #1031, thanks!
Please count me in...:) You are more than welcome to stop by and take part in our giveaway too...#81 Thank you! samjerus(at)yahoo.com
I love goodie bags! Please count me in and I hope you get a chance to fly on by my giveaway #999 xxx
Lovely! angelandspot(at)yahoo.com
Charming and a beautiful blog with a stunning treasures!So many goodies!!
My first year with OWOH and I love visiting all the amazing blogs! I am flying on my magic carpet ,visiting from Connecticut.
Thanks for the lovely giveaway.
I am blog #937
matternu@gmail.com
What a lovely giveaway! Please enter my name and come visit my blog to enter mine as well.
Cheers
Heather
OWOH #978
Great! Thanks for this nice giveaway. I want to win. Long live OWOH:)
http://sweepstakelover.blogspot.com/
http://sweepstakelover.blogcu.com/
annabell_lee_dk (at) yahoo.com
Oh i see some great stuff there! Enter me please
reviewsbyabby at gmail dot com
Lovely gifts! I want in!
shiki6210 at gmail dot com
What a wonderful giveaway! Please count me in! Hugs Rowena
craftypagan@gmail.com
Looks like a great collection! Please enter me and feel free to hop over to my blog and enter mine if you haven't already... ^-^
This giveaway looks to be full of surprises! Ples enter me. And THank you for a chance to win!
k
http://artful-musings-of-kathyl.blogspot.com/
I would love to be included in your drawing.
Sandra
Hello from Victoria, Australia.
What a lovely and generous giveaway.
I have signed up to your blog so I can follow it some more too.
Please enter me into the draw.
Thanks Lynda
http://taylormadeinoztales.blogspot.com/
So beautiful! Would love to win!
*Smiles* debbi
hockman1(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
How lovely!!!!
Please count me in...
And do pop by my home to see what I put on my magic carpet!*wink
I am no.950.
Have a safe ride, dear...it's quite far! :)
Looks a fun assortment!
wonderful giveaway, please stop by mine on your travels! #772
Cheers to Etsy Team Columbus!!
I am looking forward to visiting again;)
cyclona66(at)aol(dot)com
great giveaway - please count me in =) if you have time, i hope you can stop by my blog too!
OWOH #866
Thanks for the giveaway!!
great giveaway, I'd love to win!
shou.milk@gmail.com
What a great blog and a great giveaway.
http://usingupallthatstuff.blogspot.com/2010/01/one-world-one-heart-lets-ride-magic.html
Your giveaway is heavenly! Please enter me in the draw, and don't forget to fly my way (#922)!
Hugs,
Heavenly Humor
Thanks for the opportunity to win this, your blog is wonderful! If you have time, I hope you can visit my blog here
Yay! Gift bags are fun! Thank you so much
With lots of love from Tennessee USA #1035
What a generous giveaway! Thank you so much for giving us the chance to win such lovely gifts. :)
clogzilla(at)yahoo(dot)com
Thanks for the chance to win. Stop by & enter my giveaway too! :)
Hello from your neighbor in Toledo! Please put my name in the hat for your generous prizes.
http://leslie-mylifeandtimes.blogspot.com/
Hello...I can't find your blogger follow button :(
nice giveaways!
Please toss my name in the hat!
I am NEW to blogging (http://piecesoffatesusan.blogspot.com/) but not to art.
Come visit me #1089
Greetings from the New Jersey Shore, USA
Susan
awesome giveaways!Please enter me in your drawing and stop by my blog for my ATC giveaway! youch17(at)yahoo(dot)com
Greetings & Salutations,
Enchanting OWOH Giveaways!
Lovely Work & Blog.
For a little Glitter & Magic fly by my blog
#242 On The List @:
http://todaysgold.com
Cosmic Blessings´¨)
¸.•´¸.•*´¨) ¸.•*´¨)
(¸.•´ (¸.•´Lyndy Ward
Fantastic giveaway, I love surprises.
What fun it must be to have a team of you working toether. Quite the grouping of items you've chosen for your gifts. Your giveaway is terrific! I would love a chance to win. Please add my name to your drawing! Thanks for participating in the OWOH event.
visionquest2020 (at) msn (dot) com
Great giveaway! Please count me in.
Come to enter my giveaway if you haven't already (i'm #481) =D
Let's continue the ride on the magic carpet!
Wonderful idea! Count me in!
wow, this is a great giveaway, thank you for the chance to win, hlcarroll@hotmail.co.uk xx
Hello from the north of 60°, land of midnight sun and Aurora Borealis. I hope that you are enjoying ride on the magical carpet as much as I do. Please enter my name in your draw.
FABULOUS offerings!! Please enter my name in your drawing :) What a FUN event...enjoy the ride!!
Angie--Southeast, Texas #57
www.angiehallhaviland.typepad.com
OH please sign me up!!! And please check out my blog for more OWOH action!!
This sounds like a fun way to have surprise gifts. Please add me to your give away. If you have a chance stop by my blog #651 and enter to enter to win. rachae19@mindspring.com
great giveaway! please enter me in your giveaway!
So nice to meet you and visit your blog. Please add me to the drawing for your giveaway. I'd love for you to come visit me when you have the time!
cherryjane65@yahoo.com
http://cherryjane65.blogspot.com
Fab! count me in please! i'm #328 :)
Katie
~x~
beautiful!
Your gifts are just lovely!! I would love to win, please enter my name into your drawing! And if you haven't already, please enter mine #135 to win 1 of 3 prizes!!!
Thank you, and nice meeting you!
Peace & Love from New Zealand...
surprises are magical.. thanks for your combined efforts and the opportunity here.. .. t c
mitz_zee@yahoodotcom
Thank you so much for entering me in your awesome drawing. What a great collection of goodies. Please come by mine at #99 if you haven't had a chance.
Oh, I love eclectic mixes! Thanks for the chance1
Hope you've been able to drop by my giveaway too: http://kidney-garden.blogspot.com/2010/01/one-world-one-heart-2010-this-familys.html
Michaele (michaelek1(at)yahoo(dot)com)
Love your blog and give away. Good luck in all the drawings. stop by www.alteredpaperarts.blogspot.com
What a lovely giveaway! Combo prizes are always so wonderful. Your blog is great too! Thanks for the opportunity to be counted in for the draw.
*smiles*
Carol
Hi from England! I'd love to be included in your giveaway, thank you.
If you haven't already, please visit my blog at #711 on the magic carpet to win a designer Cath Kidston bag, handmade by me!
What an awesome giveaway! I would love to win.
Karla
It's nice to meet you! Thank you for a chance to win your wonderful giveaway! Don't forget to visit all 3 of my blogs as I am giving away something at all of them!
Monica
http://giddygreetings.com
http://thezenlens.com
http://www.ggcaa.com
giddygreetings at yahoo dot com
WOW! Please stop by my blog(#921)!
What a group of talented people. Fantastic giveaway. I would love a chance to win. Please enter me.
Anji
anji.gallanos@gmail.com
http://anjigallanos.blogspot.com
Great giveaway! Thanks for the chance to win.
Jax
Wonderful goodies! Please count me in. Enjoy your magic carpet ride. #276
What a wonderful giveaway. Got a chance to take a peek at the blog and I enjoyed it. Count me in.
Regina :>
jtrt143@aol.com
How pretty. I would love to be entered into you drawing. So glad OWOH brought me to your blog. :-)
Michelle
mouse1996@gmail.com
Nice knowing your team, and excited to know what's that batch of goodies! :)
Christina from Manila, Philippines here! Nice to meet you!
I hope you can also drop by #615!
http://calej.blogspot.com
♥ Blessings! ♥
calejbitsvyk(at)gmail(dot)com
What a lovely lot of goodies, love your etsy too :)
What a fun giveaway, count me in please.
My OWOH giveaway is for one of the fine art photographs in my etsy shop - stop by and see what strikes your fancy.
Off to go check out your shops now!
Hi there,
What lovely prizes -- thanks for offering the chance to win such goodies. :)
If a glass bead necklace sounds good, you might want to visit my blog. It would be a pleasure to welcome you there. :)
Greetings from Munich,
Birgit
swappinghowdies@yahoo.de
# 849
Greetings from an Ohio neighbor and fan!
May you have a Happy Valentine's Day!
pumpkinlady430@yahoo.com
I hope I'm not too late. I would love a chance to win.
Sophie in Montreal, Canada
Post a Comment